Which Windows Vista is the right one for universities?

My colleague Michael Green wrote this article in his US university blog, and I thought it was worth repetition:

"Determining which Vista to install is not as complicated as you might think.  Vista Business contains most of what you are looking for out of an "everyday" work machine, including the capability to logon to a domain.  Assuming the "Business" as a base, we can construct a simple list of differences.

Business > Enterprise

BitLocker Drive Encryption

Subsystem for Unix Applications

Support for simultaneous installation of multiple user interface languages

Software Assurance Benefit - Install up to 4 additional copies of Windows in Virtual Machines on the Enterprise host

Enterprise > Ultimate

Themed slide shows

Native DVD playback

Windows Media Center

HD version of Movie Maker

Parental Controls

I often hear people say things like "Ultimate cannot connect to servers" or "Ultimate cannot be managed by Group Policy".  Those are incorrect statements.  Ultimate is a superset of Enterprise to add the consumer functionality like Media Center.  When you hear someone say that Ultimate cannot be managed using GPOs, what they really mean is that out of the list of features above that are specific to Ultimate, there are no GPOs to manage them.  The GPOs for Vista were designed with the feature set of Business and Enterprise in mind.  Home Premium and Home Basic are not able to join a domain but Ultimate can.  All versions of Vista can connect to servers.

So if you are deploying a computer lab which version should you choose?  Assuming that the hardware provider has provided DVD playback software, Enterprise is the best choice.  Enterprise was designed for large deployments and provides volume methods of activation to do so.  With Ultimate, Microsoft has to keep track of the DVD codec since there is a royalty due to a 3rd party.  As such, there must be a key that is per machine."

Skip to main content