My views on SOPA


During my 4-part series write up on SOPA, I approached it with a neutral tone.  I was hearing from everywhere that it was a horrible piece of legislation, but I wanted to find out for myself.  The goal was to look at it from the technical perspective and compare it to what’s going on today from the abuse angle, and then look at it from the non-technical ramifications.  Were the decries from everywhere overheated rhetoric?  Or was there substance?

I then wanted to look at some of the criticisms and see whether or not they are valid.  I have long since learned that if you’re firmly attached to one side of the debate, it becomes emotional.  Once it becomes emotional, it doesn’t matter whether or not you are right or wrong; you just hold firmly to your position.  In the past, I have done this very thing which is why I tried to avoid looking at it from the point of view that “SOPA is bad!” or “We need this to stop online piracy!”

I see from one of my commenters that I’ve been accused of being a shill for industry.  I guess that comes from the subject line of my blog post not coming out against the legislation.  It also comes with the territory of writing about controversial topics.

I wasn’t explicit about which way I leaned in my blog posts, although if you read carefully you can figure it out.

  • I said that some criticisms were spurious, but I also said others were valid.
  • I said that the entertainment industry is going to have to change their business model.
  • I said that cracking down on copyright infringement would make the Internet boring, and I then posted a clip to a piece of copyrighted material.

Without resorting to hyperbole and looking at both sides, you should know where I stand.

Comments (17)

  1. I agree with you.  You don't seem to like it.  I don't.  I signed somebody's petition the other day against it too, and I'm proud of it.  

  2. Lyria says:

    Ha. If only it was that simple. The internet it's a quick and easy way to get informed, it's education in the palm of our hand.

    Haven't you come to think about it?: Maybe the government knows that an un-educated country is easier to manipulate.

  3. Well, it's dead now, and maybe the stupid bill will stay that way?  

  4. kelvinlin says:

    I agree! And I'm proud of it<a href="http://www.okawards.com"&gt;.</a>

  5. masters for dissertation says:

    I was effective and unexpectedly I visit your site regularly and advisory it to me to study also.

    dissertation-masters.co.uk

  6. online perth tickets says:

    Perth Concert tickets accessible here. Acquire all Australia concert tickets at very sensible cost. <a href="http://www.diamondboxoffice.com">online perth tickets</a>

  7. Amy Hamilton says:

    As you have posted an article of so much knowledge, Your article has truly peaked my interest.

    <a href="http://www.essayyard.co.uk/">UK Essay Service</a>

  8. justin says:

    Really your post is really very good and I appreciate it. <a href="http://www.courseworkhelppros.co.uk/…/">science coursework assistance</a> || <a href="http://www.courseworkhelppros.co.uk/…/">maths coursework assistance</a>

  9. justin says:

    Really your post is really very good and I appreciate it. http://www.courseworkhelppros.co.uk/science-coursework

  10. Mark says:

    I appreciate your work your post is really very good. http://www.britishwritinghelp.co.uk/assignment-writing.php

  11. mak says:

    I agree with you.  You don't seem to like it.  I don't.  I signed somebody's petition the other day against it too, and I'm proud of it.  

    http://iphone-6-price.in/India

  12. Kevin Lackey says:

    I am happy to find this post very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. I always prefer to read the quality content and this thing I found in you post. Thanks for sharing. http://www.uaeassignment.blogspot.ae

  13. jacquelinef says:

    This is usually a good eye-catching send out. We've been basically information concerning your very own non-public effective perform. Anybody choice critically remarkable reality. http://www.terbia.net/

  14. Greg Sheen says:

    I think writing with criticism can be a pretty challenging task as you stand on tight rope actually with the possibility of angering some of the readers. But you also build a loyal readership. <a href="http://www.essayarsenal.co.uk/…/a&gt;

  15. Greg Sheen says:

    I think writing with criticism can be a pretty challenging task as you stand on tight rope actually with the possibility of angering some of the readers. But you also build a loyal readership. Again. http://www.essayarsenal.co.uk/dissertation-help-uk.aspx

  16. DANNY says:

    hey this site is great, man 🙂 Thank you for sharing.very good posted

    http://www.adanabilgisayartamiri.com/urunler.asp

  17. micheal jones says:

    I really enjoyed reading your article. I found this as an informative and interesting post, so i think it is very useful and knowledgeable. I would like to thank you for the effort you have made in writing this article.