In some ways I take Rob’s point – using HTML5 because it’s new or shiny or cool isn’t the best of reasons for doing this kind of thing. (Although I admit, I like cool stuff as much as anyone.)
In addition, it shows that games in particular do not need to be propped up by Flash to work. Take Angry Birds for Chrome, for example. While pretty much everything is HTML5, audio is Flash. If you’re going to do this, you might as well stick with Flash. Instead, Cut the Rope uses SoundManager which uses HTML5 audio in the first instance and falls back to flash for browser that have trouble with doing it natively. If flash isn’t available, you’re not going to get locked out.
That aside, where I am in violent agreement with Rob is where he says “it is a wonderful way to deploy games to a large number of uses across nearly all devices in a standard manner.” It’s this ability to extend the reach of an app that makes HTML5 such a valuable addition to the developer’s kitbag.
If the tech beauty parade at CES shows anything, it’s that the proliferation of devices is in rude health. And while this feeds the soul of my inner geek, it presents a real challenge for developers. Now, HTML5 might not be the only solution but it is becoming a viable option for a growing number of these challenges.