I could be completely wrong, but I'm always suspicious when I hear the Monster Truck Announcer Voice or That Announcer Guy from the Movies in a radio spot (or booth babes pitching a technology product at a convention). So when I see a network card initially priced @ $279 and a website that's a glitz and Flash to promote... a NIC, even a Killer NIC, I get suspicious. Maybe I'm just a caveman from one of those horrible car insurance commercials and maybe I only play online games through my Xbox (which doesn't seem to have a user-serviceable NIC anyway), but... A network card that has more RAM and processing power than all of the first five computers that I owned combined?! Who needs that? Kids these days, I tell ya'. Don't get me started on walking to school uphill in the snow, either. The horror!
Seriously, though. How much "poor gaming performance" is due to my local network latency or packet processing overhead by comparison with how much is crappy rendering software in the game, screw-ups down the ISP's cable that I have no control of or overloaded servers hosting the game at the cheapskate game publisher's NOC? For that much scratch, I could almost buy my wife and kids their own 360 and never have to share again! Heh.
What do YOU think? Kewl n00b hardware – or – scam? Is there a difference?