To VB or not to VB: VB.NET or C# — which one should you choose?


I get asked pretty often which of these two languages I prefer.  I prefer C#.  But which one should you choose?  That depends.


*  If you have lots of legacy VB code, VB.NET may be a better choice.  VB.NET is a full-featured language and rivals C# in features and productivity.  They both derive their features and personalities from the CLR, so it’s no surprise that most of the differences between them are more syntactical than semantical.


*  If you are coming to managed code from C or C++, by all means give C# a try first.  It’s really just another language in the C family, and you’ll be right at home in no time.


*  If you are new to coding in general or have no previous exposure to either C/C++ or VB.NET, I’d say it’s a toss-up.  Which one you should go with really comes down to your individual skills and tastes.  As for C#, the fact that it’s case-sensitive is about the only thing I can think of that might trip up a newbie trying to get up to speed with the language.  I find C# to be, in general, a more elegant language that is simpler to learn and simpler to use, but there are plenty of folk who don’t feel that way.  For me, the ease-of-use chasm that used to exist between the VB family of languages and the C family vanished with the advent of C#, but other people still find VB.NET code easier to read than any flavor of C, including C#. 


*  If you have a mix of the above conditions, you might end up using both.  That’s no crime, and is a perfectly reasonable thing to do given the right circumstances.  You can inherit from/use a class created in one language in the other (actually in _any_ managed code app), and, in fact, you’re probably already doing that every time you build a VB.NET app because it uses classes in the Framework that were likely written in C#.


So, I won’t presume to tell you what’s best for you.  I’ll just say that each language has its place, and which one you go with depends on your specific circumstances.


 


Comments (4)

  1. Thank you very much, as you realy helped me make my mind. I am new to both and struggling to decide which one should i go for. AND HERE IT IS, I decided to take your joice of c# and realy i was in a mess as my mind say VB.NET and my feeling say C# as I realy feel even better after i took "Beggining C# Objects" and couldn’t stop till chapter 3 so many thanks.

    Other thing which i think may help other people who struggling to decide as I been, I think C# will be the most powerfull language in the coming future and more people will be migrating to C# specially if .NET become avaliable on linux and other platforms.

  2. YeYan says:

    I use C and VB before,but use C# now.

  3. AB says:

    VB.NET and VB are both very shitty programming languages and very difficult to use effectively

    C++  rules!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!