Current as of 08/01/2011 – Check the Resources listed below for more up-to-date information on this topic
Security for any computing platform involves three primary areas:
- Principals (users or programmatic access to an asset or other program)
- Securables (objects, data or programs that can be accessed)
- Channels (methods of access by Principals to Securables)
On-premise systems normally use a central system to control security. In a Windows operating system-based environment, this is often accomplished with Active Directory or other systems that provide sign-on and user identity information. While other networking security paradigms have different terminology, all involve the three areas defined above.
In addition to the names and passwords for a user, Active Directory (like other security mechanisms) store other information about Principals – called Claims. These claims can include any custom fields the provider allows. In many networks, these fields are not used heavily, because applications that eventually need to secure the assets they control are not always deployed on the same platforms everywhere.
In a single environment, security is often quite simple. A Principal is created such as a user or group, and then the Principal is granted access to a Securable such as a a folder, database or other asset. Permissions or Rights (or both) combine to allow a particular Principal to read, write, delete or edit data, or to access or run a particular program.
Figure 1 – On-premise security environment example
The simplicity of this arrangement is due to a single, homogenous boundary. Even if more than one location is used, the Principals and Securables are grouped into a single logical boundary that is managed from one location.
This background serves as the starting point for the Federating Security topic below.
Windows Azure Security Boundaries
Windows Azure is a series of resources – servers, data and service buses, in addition to other features. Developers write code, and the deploy that to the Azure environment.
Figure 2 – Azure Components
The code or data can be deployed to use one or more of the services. In other words, the Web Role in Windows Azure might host a simple website, and no other component need be used.
Figure 3 – Simple Azure Web Role Application – only one feature used
Or, a complex mix of Web, Worker and Data Services, along with a Service Bus, RDBS and even on-site systems can be grouped into a much larger program.
Figure 4 – Complex Windows and SQL Azure Application With Multiple Interactions
For a more basic introduction to Windows and SQL Azure, see this link: https://channel9.msdn.com/Events/TechEd/Europe/2010/COS322
Windows Azure, like any web-based property, has three general layers of security:
- Physical Access
- Operating Environment (Including the Operating System itself)
- Data and Programmatic Security
Each of these layers have additional layers within themselves, and this forms the basis of a secure experience for the end user or program. Some of these layers are the responsibility of Microsoft; others are the responsibility of the architect and developer; others are a joint or shared responsibility of both Microsoft and the client.
Layer One: Physical Access
The first layer of security within a web property such as Windows or SQL Azure is a secure facility. the following data points are important to understand for the worldwide facilities that host Windows and SQL Azure:
- Microsoft Global Foundation Services (GFS) is responsible for the physical security of the datacenters located worldwide for Windows and SQL Azure. Information on Microsoft datacenters can be found here: http://www.globalfoundationservices.com/
- The address and exact locations facilities are not commonly documented for security reasons.
- Microsoft runs it’s own data centers and does not contract this function out.
- The GFS controlled facilities hold an ISO/IEC 27001:2005 certification, and are audited to SAS level II.
- Standard secure operations protocols are in place, including least-privilege access.
Layer Two: Operating Environment
Windows Azure and SQL Azure do not currently hold certifications. Microsoft does not comment on the security certifications being pursued for Windows or SQL Azure. That being said, the Windows Azure environment is based on a modified Windows 2008 R2 Enterprise environment, developed using the Trustworthy Computing Initiative (TCI).
The system controlling the host machines and their guest environments that ultimately hold the Web and Worker Roles within Windows Azure is called the Fabric – not to be confused with the Application Fabric feature. The Fabric is not accessible by client code – it controls the inner workings of Windows Azure, including Load-balancing, system restarts, maintenance and monitoring.
Within the host machines that house the Web and Worker Roles, special networking constructs broker all conversations between Virtual Machines. Virtual Machines – even ones configured to communicate with each other – move through this network. Direct-machine to machine communication is not allowed, protecting one application from another or one data construct from another.
Figure 5 – Windows Azure Fabric
Windows and SQL Azure support only TCP-based communications. Ports commonly used are:
- 80 – Default public port used for Web Roles – can be enabled/disabled per configuration
- 443 – Default secure port used for Web roles – can be enabled/disabled per configuration
- 9350-9353 – These ports are used by the Windows Azure AppFabric service bus bindings. Refer to http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ee732535.aspx for more details
- 1433 – SQL Azure
- 3389 – This port is used for RDP access to VM-based roles, only if enabled
Layer Three: Data and Programmatic Security
All internal access through use of keys only. Without the proper key, code or data will not transfer. Storage Accounts have individual keys, so in this manner different security layers may be applied not only programmatically but at the account layer.
Figure 6 – Windows Azure communications between components
Calls to Windows Azure are made using standard SOAP, XML or REST-based protocols. The communications channel can be encrypted between the client and Windows Azure or allow it to remain unencrypted based on security needs.
SQL Azure uses the standard SQL Server Tabular Data Stream (TDS) protocol, but only allows encrypted communications.
Data is unencrypted within Windows Azure Blob or Table Storage – but is only accessible via the key for a storage account. Data can be encrypted client-side and stored in Windows Azure in an encrypted fashion. Microsoft does not inspect internal data for validity or encryption enforcement. The key is that the data is client-side encrypted and decrypted.
Figure 7 – Example data at rest encryption scenario
Alternatively, a hybrid solution can store sensitive data locally and non-sensitive data in Azure Storage. The data can be coalesced at the client level such that the data is never transferred over any channel not owned or controlled by the organization.
In the case of a single security boundary for Windows Azure, multiple security options are available. Users can be anonymously authorized, such as in the case of a public website for advertisement or informational purposes.
Another option is to create an Internet Information Services (IIS) Internal Security Store. This is not a best-practice (although still possible) approach since the Fabric services within Windows Azure may recycle an instance and the session may sever between a given role and a client. Architecting stateless applications is a preferred approach.
Using Claims-Based Authentication is a better solution. In this approach, the Principal is authenticated through a trusted party, such as Active Directory, OpenID, OpenAuthentication, or LiveID. Many web-properties use these methods, such as Microsoft, Google, Yahoo and Facebook to name a few. After authenticating with one of these services, the client is issued Claims using the WS-Federation (WS-Fed) or Security Assertion Markup Language (SAML) that are passed to Windows Azure. At no time does Windows Azure store, transfer or interrogate the Principal’s security token. Claims can be anything from a group or role membership to location or any other settable attribute. Assets are then secured allowing only the Claim, without regard to the user’s location or access method. In this fashion a single security paradigm covers the Securables, with the Principals being controlled in any number of other mechanisms. This allows single-sign-on and/or federated security access from multiple providers.
The simplest mechanism for building this environment is the Access Control Services (ACS) feature found in the Windows Azure Application Fabric component. It is a federated authorization management service that simplifies user access authorization across organizations and ID providers and performs claims transformation to map identities with access levels.
- Create and manage scopes such as URLs
- Create and manage claim types
- Create and manage signing and encryption keys
- Create and manage rules within an application scope
- Chain claims rules
- Manage permissions on scopes or perform delegation
Figure 8 – Federated Security Example
Full information on the Access Control Service is available at this link: http://social.technet.microsoft.com/wiki/contents/articles/windows-identity-foundation-wif-and-azure-appfabric-access-control-service-acs-survival-guide.aspx?wa=wsignin1.0
Since the Web and Worker Roles within Windows Azure are designed to be stateless, Microsoft created a Certification Store within the Management area to hold Certificates that can be called from within code. An example of using the Certification Store is here: http://blogs.msdn.com/b/jnak/archive/2010/01/29/installing-certificates-in-windows-azure-vms.aspx
Official, authoritative security resource list: http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ff934690.aspx
Technical Overview of the Security Features in the Windows Azure Platform: http://www.microsoft.com/online/legal/?langid=en-us&docid=11.
Windows Azure Security Overview: http://www.globalfoundationservices.com/security/documents/WindowsAzureSecurityOverview1_0Aug2010.pdf
Windows Azure Privacy: http://www.microsoft.com/online/legal/?langid=en-us&docid=11
Securing Microsoft Cloud Infrastructure: http://www.globalfoundationservices.com/security/documents/SecuringtheMSCloudMay09.pdf.
A list of other security resources is here: http://blogs.msdn.com/b/buckwoody/archive/2010/12/07/windows-azure-learning-plan-security.aspx
Image Attribution: David Pallmann: http://davidpallmann.blogspot.com/2011/07/windows-azure-design-patterns-part-1.html